Lost Opportunities: Unmade Alien 5 with Cameron & Scott | Sci-Fi Legacy

Alien 5 : In the world of science fiction and horror cinema, the Alien franchise has established itself as an iconic and enduring series. The terrifying Xenomorphs, Ripley’s indomitable spirit, and the suspense-filled storytelling have left an indelible mark on the genre. Yet, despite its success, there remains a tantalizing what-if scenario that has fascinated fans for years: the unmade Alien 5, a project that would have brought together two legendary directors, James Cameron and Ridley Scott.

Lost Opportunities Unmade Alien 5 with Cameron & Scott Sci-Fi Legacy

The Origins of Alien 5

After the release of “Alien: Resurrection,” 20th Century Fox was eager to continue the franchise’s legacy with a fifth installment. They entrusted the script to Joss Whedon, who had previously worked on “Alien: Resurrection.” Whedon’s vision for the sequel was ambitious and promised something entirely new.

Tom Rothman, Fox’s president of production at the time, expressed his optimism, saying, “Joss Whedon will write it, and we expect to have Sigourney and Winona if they’re up for it.” This statement ignited excitement among fans who hoped for a grand continuation of the Alien saga.

Whedon, speaking about his project, teased, “There’s a big story to tell in another sequel. The fourth film is really a prologue to a movie set on Earth. Imagine all the things that can happen. If I write this movie, and it has my writing credits on it, then it’s going to be on Earth … And it’s going to be very different from the last one.”

The Vision for Alien 5

Whedon’s vision for “Alien 5,” tentatively titled “Alien: Revelation,” was groundbreaking. He wanted to take the franchise to Earth, breaking away from the confined spaces of previous films. He explained, “The time of people running around in a tin can has passed. You have to work on a broader canvas; otherwise, it becomes an episode and not a new movie. The way Cameron exploded from the first to the second, you have to do that again, and that means going somewhere new.”

Fans were excited by the prospect of seeing the Xenomorphs unleashed on Earth, and Whedon’s promise of something completely different from what had been seen before only added to the anticipation.

The Abandoned Project

Unfortunately, Whedon’s enthusiasm for the project waned after the release of “Alien: Resurrection.” He expressed his disinterest in making somebody else’s franchise, and his focus shifted to other ventures, particularly his work with Marvel and DC on their respective franchise films. Thus, “Alien: Revelation” was put on hold, and fans were left wondering what could have been.

Other Unfulfilled Ideas

Over the years, there were other whispers of potential Alien 5 projects. One notable rumor involved Ripley 8 heading to the Alien homeworld to confront the Xenomorphs. However, these ideas never materialized into actual films, leaving fans with only tantalizing hints of unexplored storylines.

Sigourney Weaver, who portrayed Ripley, once mused, “I’ve always wanted to do one [an Alien movie] where we go back to the planet from which the Alien originally came.” While this idea remained a tantalizing possibility, it never came to fruition.

The Cameron-Scott Collaboration

Perhaps the most intriguing unmade project was the collaboration between James Cameron and Ridley Scott on an Alien film. In the early 2000s, rumors surfaced that the two renowned directors were exploring the idea of working together on the franchise.

Scott expressed his openness to the project, stating, “I’ve been asked about Alien 5, and I said, of course. We’ve started a script meeting. I mean, I’ve started it off so I may as well close the door – if in fact this is meant to be the last one.” He even hinted at Arnold Schwarzenegger potentially joining the Alien universe.

Cameron confirmed the discussions, saying, “What came up was the idea of doing Alien 5,” and they had conversations about the project. The prospect of two visionary directors joining forces for an Alien sequel was tantalizing, to say the least.

Unfulfilled Plotlines

While the details of the unmade Alien 5 and 6 plots are speculative, they offered intriguing directions for the franchise. Alien 5 was rumored to be set on Earth, with the planet under attack from alien warrior dropships. Ripley’s involvement in these events would have created a compelling narrative.

Alien 6, on the other hand, was said to take place on the navigator’s home planet, exploring the spread of the Xenomorphs to other worlds. These unfulfilled plotlines hinted at a broader and more expansive Alien universe.

The Lost Opportunity

Regrettably, the tantalizing prospect of Cameron and Scott collaborating on an Alien sequel never came to pass. The project was ultimately shelved, with Cameron attributing its demise to the release of “Alien vs. Predator.” Fox’s decision to prioritize the crossover film over the potential masterpiece of Cameron and Scott’s collaboration remains a controversial one among fans.

In conclusion, the unmade Alien 5 project, along with the unrealized potential of a James Cameron and Ridley Scott collaboration, continues to be a subject of fascination and regret for fans of the franchise. While the Alien series has left an indelible mark on the world of cinema, one can’t help but wonder what could have been if these visionary projects had seen the light of day.


The Alien franchise has a rich history of suspense and horror, and the unmade projects surrounding Alien 5 and the potential collaboration between James Cameron and Ridley Scott remain a testament to its enduring legacy. While these projects never materialized, they serve as a reminder of the boundless creativity and imagination that the world of science fiction cinema has to offer.


1. Why did Joss Whedon lose interest in Alien 5?

Joss Whedon lost interest in Alien 5 after the release of “Alien: Resurrection.” He expressed a desire to focus on creating his own original content rather than working on someone else’s franchise.

2. What were the rumored plotlines for Alien 5 and 6?

The rumored plotline for Alien 5 involved an alien invasion of Earth, with Ripley playing a central role in the story. Alien 6 was said to take place on the navigator’s home planet and explored the spread of the Xenomorphs to other worlds.

3. Why did the collaboration between James Cameron and Ridley Scott for Alien 5 not happen?

The collaboration between James Cameron and Ridley Scott for Alien 5 never materialized, primarily due to the studio’s decision to prioritize “Alien vs. Predator.” Cameron cited this as the reason for the project’s demise.

4. Is there still hope for a new Alien film in the future?

While there have been no official announcements, the Alien franchise remains beloved by fans, and there is always the possibility of new entries in the future. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top